Another County Hopes to Become a City: A New Roadmap for a St. Louis County-City Merger?

Another County Hopes to Become a City: A New Roadmap for a St. Louis County-City Merger?

According to the Washington Post, Fairfax County, VA Executive Anthony Griffin has proposed that the County become a city. In various ways quite a few cities have done this, notably close to St. Louis are Indianapolis and Louisville. The idea seems to be targeted primarily towards have greater control over taxes and road maintenance. This could prove very important as the Virginia State Legislature has failed repeatedly to produce a plan and the funding to address the challenges in Fairfax County, but I tend to agree that the symbolism is important as well. From The City Fix-DC:

To my mind, though, the most important impact of becoming a city rather than a county is the symbolic power of that act. It’s impossible to quantify, but the mayor of what would be the region’s largest city (around 1 million residents versus the District’s 600,000) is going to think of himself more urbanly than the county executive of the same area would. Those who move to the largest city in Virginia will think of that choice as something different, even if they live in the same house or apartment they otherwise would have. Perceptions matter; symbols


Of course the bigger question for those of us in St. Louis is whether this may present another option to finally de-splinter our glut of municipal governments; the City of St. Louis and the 150 political jurisdictions including 91 municipalities of St. Louis County. It would seem that the much bigger challenge is to unify the County into a City and perhaps not unifying the County with St. Louis City. It seems that there may be less resistance from smaller municipalities if they weren't joining St. Louis City. And if the time did come for a merger of St. Louis County and City just two entities would be involved, not 92.

Similar to Fairfax County, St. Louis County would be a city of just more than 1,000,000 people and by far the largest city in the metro region (St. Louis City has 350,000 residents). Again, it may be symbolic or simply perception, but as the Mayor of a city and not a "County Executive" don't you think Charlie Dooley would think a little more "urbanly"? After all, in most minds a "city" of 1,000,000 needs a mass transportation system, including mass transit, while a county needs roads.


NextSTL is committed to providing original stories and unique perspectives on a variety of urban topics such as architecture, development, transportation, historic preservation, urban planning and design and public policy in St. Louis. We're always looking to add new, diverse voices to the mix. We accept anonymous tips, pitches for story ideas, and completed stories.

Learn More