Wellston Loop and “Great Streets” – Thoughts On Design Charrette Part 1

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook70Share on Reddit0Share on LinkedIn6Print this pageEmail this to someone

The City of St. Louis and the East-West Gateway Coordinating Council of Governments recently sponsored a “Great Streets Initiative” for Dr. Martin Luther King Drive from Union Boulevard west to the City Limits. The attention being paid to this part of our city is commendable and needs to be followed up by actual improvements on the ground. Deterioration in the Wellston Loop area has reached a critical point: without substantial efforts to shore up historic structures very soon, an important part of our city’s history and culture will be erased and the opportunity to revitalize a vibrant, diverse community will have been lost.

My comments below are based on a series of events which took place the week of Monday, April 11, 2016, over four days. The meetings took place at 5736 Dr. Martin Luther King Drive, a historic building being renovated by Ward 22 Alderman Jeffrey Boyd. Consultants met with business owners and residents with the goal of developing meaningful plans to spur the area’s revitalization.

fig-1-great-streets-title{Figure 1, Title Slide. The introductory slide for the “Public Wrap Up & Next Steps” session held on Thursday, April 14, 2016.}

It’s important that attention is paid to this neighborhood which has been in dire need of reinvestment and support to counteract decades of disinvestment and flight. I applaud the cooperation of Don Roe, the city’s Planning and Urban Design Agency, East-West Gateway Council of Governments and Ward 22 Alderman Jeffrey Boyd for co-sponsoring this public design process.

The consultants conducting the focus sessions and design charrette were CBB Transportation Engineers & Planners, RDg Planning & Design, PDS Environmental, and Development Strategies. See Figure 1 for the title slide from their final presentation from the evening of Thursday, April 14. (Images bounded by thick black frames are taken from the consultant presentation.)

My criticisms are intended to be constructive and are based on my understanding of the neighborhood, its history, and its capacity for becoming once again a vital center of commerce and culture. Continuing the planning process in regular consultation with the community is essential to developing a plan the neighborhood accepts and supports. Imposing “top down” developments can alienate current residents and dampen their positive impact.

fig-2-wellston-loop-base{Figure 2, Base Map. This slide of the “Wellston Loop Area” by RDg Planning & Design was presented as part of the proposed master plan for Dr. Martin Luther King Drive. My annotations include the blue text (top) beginning with “Base map by RDg”, the RDg logo, north arrow, and remarks in orange (lower right-hand corner).}

The overall study covers Dr. Martin Luther King Drive from Union Boulevard west to the City Limits (almost to Kienlen Avenue). The planning team divided the study area into a series of smaller sections. My focus here is on the section called the “Wellston Loop Area” as depicted in Figure 2. This particular section extends from Laurel Avenue on east (at right side) west to the City Limits on the west (left side). Figure 3 includes the street names and indicates the border between the city and county.

From a logical perspective, the study area should extend at least to Kienlen Avenue rather than stopping at the City Limits. The bureaucratic reasons behind stopping the study at this essentially arbitrary dividing line reflects the kinds of disconnect and lack of coordination between the City of St. Louis, the City of Wellston, and St. Louis County. The East-West Gateway Council should help bridge these kinds of gaps in supporting the plan’s implementation.

My remarks are largely based on the “Wellston Loop Area” slide in Figure 2. The two subsequent figures replicate this plan with the addition of street names and the city/county border in Figure 3 and a numbered key indicating specific locations in Figure 4.

fig-3-wellston-loop-streets{Figure 3, Street Names. This diagram replicates Figure 2 with the addition of street names (in orange) and the city/county boundary line (in green).}

There was a good deal of discussion between the presenters (consultants) and the audience (stakeholders) about various aspects of the plan. Public comments ranged from complimentary to quite critical. My comments here are based on my experiences working in the community. I’ve had the opportunity to know the people and the place over the past five years while co-teaching the course “Community Building, Building Community” in the Sam Fox School of Design & Visual Arts at Washington University in St. Louis.

Many people in this community have expressed their frustration with being the subject of academic studies and planning recommendations. They long for desperately needed investments which generally fail to materialize.

In any redevelopment project of a struggling neighborhood, there’s a danger that too much emphasis will be placed on economic development without adequate attention paid to the real needs the existing residents. Gentrification displaces people and relocates problems from one area to another without addressing the underlying issues. To some extent such effects are inevitable, but if considered properly, they should be minimized. People who have committed themselves to the community over the long term deserve particular attention when improvements are being made.

fig-4-wellston-loop-key{Figure 4, Key Map. This illustration uses the same base as Figure 3 with the addition of a numbered key (in yellow) highlighting specific locations (both proposed and existing).}

My remarks begin with the community’s symbolic center––the historic 1909 Wellston Station (Figure 4, Key #1)––and proceed counterclockwise around the drawing. Securing and restoring Wellston Station is absolutely critical to the revitalization of this part of Dr. MLK. The plan reflects this necessity, making it the centerpiece of a “town square / marketplace” development featuring storefront businesses, open green space and limited parking. Reestablishing a takeaway type restaurant at Wellston Station is crucial to the viability of this concept. Until recently Bus Loop Burgers was located here (see Figure 5). Similar food service businesses, like The White Mill, operated there throughout the 20th Century. The tradition of such food service businesses in this location goes back decades and to critical to establishing even the potential for revitalization.

Presently, the structure is vacant. Presumably, the tenant was asked to leave in order to allow for rehabilitation work to proceed. If this building remains shuttered and no takeaway restaurant is reestablished, then the viability of sustainably reviving Dr. MLK in the Wellston Loop will be threatened.

The plan suggests symbolically representing the position of the former Hodiamont rail lines through the use of pavers, a potentially fruitful idea. Locating a reconditioned PCC street car and positioning it under the building’s canopy could be a wonderful opportunity to visually reestablish a vibrant aspect of the neighborhood’s history as a transit hub. Currently, the Museum of Transportation in St. Louis County has an actual Hodiamont streetcar in its collection.

Carrying out such a plan would require a significant investment. However, such a renovation would substantially improve the public’s perception of the immediate surroundings. It’s important that the building not become an empty monument to history. It needs to remain a center of daily activity.

Wellston Station’s revitalization should be accomplished so as to reinforce the positive nature of existing social interactions while discouraging negative behaviors. This is a delicate balance to strike. The restored building should NOT be an immaculate cleaned up, sanitized relic of the past, but instead, should retain its function as a well-known gathering place.

Plans for the surrounding area should encourage people to sit and gather, expanding on the building’s role as a transit hub. Improvements should not discriminate amongst people with regard to race, class, home or other factors. It should NOT be policed in such a way as to drive out the “undesirable homeless people” who presently use the shelter. It should be clean, well-lit and made safe and secure to the greatest extent possible. It needs to remain an authentic hang-out spot and not become a sanitized memorial. The building needs to continue operating as an authentic social collector.

fig-5-wellston-station{Figure 5, Wellston Station. A recent photograph of Wellston Station (#1) when Bus Loop Burgers was still operating and a rendering depicting the proposed improvements to the structure which is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. (Photograph © Andrew Raimist 2015; drawing by Jeffrey A. Brambila, AIA Architects & Planners with edits and colors by Raimist.)}

Programming public events to take place here will be critical to reestablishing the perception of the area as one that’s agreeable and desirable. How this is handled will be critical for the success of any redevelopment effort. Simply fixing up the building and the immediate surroundings from a physical standpoint will not be sufficient.

The proposed mechanism for Wellston Station’s revitalization relies on encouraging a wider community of interested people to invest in it based on positive collective memories of its significance. This notion is a creative approach to the difficulties relating to financing its restoration. It’s unlikely to be restored by private developers due to the high cost involved to preserve its craftsmanship and details. Its tiny footprint together with the area’s economic challenges makes it generally unattractive for commercial redevelopment. Relying solely on public funding seems similarly unrealistic.

Making this project a reality will require establishing a nonprofit organization with the mission of restoring and revitalizing the building and its surroundings. The overall goal would extend beyond the structure and its immediate surroundings to make it an integral part of a functioning commercial district. The project would be a philanthropic effort founded on gaining the support of people with positive collective memories. Grants are available to support such a project. Citizens and businesses would need to come together to invest in bringing it back to life after being stabilized by the City of St. Louis, which owns it through the Land Reutilization Authority (LRA).

This effort will rely on people who once lived, worked or shopped here in years past and have fond recollections of the area’s position as the city’s “second downtown.” It will be no small undertaking but will nevertheless be essential to the revitalization of this part of Dr. MLK. Stabilizing the building needs to be commenced immediately, as portions of the building are presently in danger of collapse. Not only is it in a fragile state, it’s potentially dangerous to the public.

Building stabilization should include ensuring its structural integrity, including its columns, beams, and roof structure. All of the existing roofing should be removed, new plywood and roofing felt installed and the roofing slates completely reinstalled after being properly flashed using copper. New copper gutters and downspouts should be provided. Rotted wood should be replaced. Exterior wood surfaces that are sound should be cleaned, primed and painted. Ideally, the first floor should be sufficiently updated so another small restaurant could operate in that space with minimal investment infrastructure required. That is, the utility service connections should be brought up to code (electric, plumbing, gas, telephone) so they’re prepared for a new tenant to move in.

Although its enclosed footprint is small, the significance of the social interactions taking place at this structure is vital to the area. Leaving the building without a tenant would be disastrous for the structure and surrounding area. The social, economic and symbolic implications of this tiny restaurant cannot be overstated. Whenever I speak with people about the neighborhood who knew it from the past, they invariably ask me whether Wellston Station is still standing. There is a persistent rumor in some circles that the building has been condemned and is slated for imminent demolition.

The master plan suggests creating a new series of small structures (#2), highlighted in red, across the north side of the Wellston Station property where it backs up to Hope House (#3). The plan proposes extending Theodosia Avenue west for one block past Hodiamont Avenue to Irving Avenue. The necessity of formally extending this street is questionable. Creating an access drive or alleyway here may be sufficient to provide service entries for the proposed new structures as well as allowing vehicular access to Hope House. Extending the street would necessarily be a part of the planning for the construction of these new buildings.

The purpose of this series of new buildings (#2) is providing small-scale, pedestrian-oriented retail space. Potentially, they could offer outdoor dining in a protected area. This kind of business located around Wellston Station would help to reinforce the welcoming nature of this public square. Having accessible, engaging storefronts here would help animate the space where the side of Hope House (#3) overlooks mostly unused deteriorated pavement. The existing restroom facility constructed by Metro should either be demolished as part of the redevelopment or redesigned to work as a public facility.

*Andrew’s review of the Wellston Loop design charrette first appeared on his site Architectural Ruminations

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook70Share on Reddit0Share on LinkedIn6Print this pageEmail this to someone
  • gmichaud

    I know this area well. For many years I was involved with Union West Community Corp. They did new homes on Wells near Friendly Temple, rehabs on Rowan Ave and elsewhere, facilitated the ball park on Wells, had computer classes for adults and students, Christmas programs and so on. The non profit was shut down because of politics. There was a student from Washington U, a grad student who did a project, basically a precursor to Great Streets on Martin Luther King in this area. This was when Kenny Jones was still alderman to give some perspective of timing. I remember he proposed a statue of Martin Luther King in the middle of the road for vista purposes, making the road go around the statue. Not a bad idea I always thought
    He focused on the streetscape and improvements.
    I have tried to find more detailed info on this charette you cite. There are none at either of the companies mentioned nor at East West Gateway.
    First let me speak to what might work. For starters the study should have extended at least to the metro rail station in Pagedale and to downtown St. Louis, where MLK ends at the Convention Center and picks up at the Martin Luther King Bridge.
    The analysis of transit is central to economic development and should generate a public space, a plaza. For instance make the parking lot adjacent to the Wellston Station a plaza that leaves the existing Youngs Cafe Building in place, maybe with a fountain in the middle.
    A paved public space, like a plaza, is cheap to form and is basically just paving.. It is a canvas for the community.
    A farmers market, more importantly markets with individual stalls that enable even the smallest entrepreneur to participate, those kind of markets can be formed as well as cultural events, a high school choir, a festival. The creation of public space allows for community expression.
    Nor am I saying that the location next to the Wellston Station is the best, an analysis of transit, north south routes and other approaches are needed. I am saying that the St. Louis transit system as it stands is a poor value and could serve the public much better by reorganizing the transit routes to help neighborhoods with economic development.
    This is what the charette should be looking at from my perspective. In any case the establishment of public space along this stretch of MLK Blvd is what the public needs in terms of economic and cultural opportunity.
    Truthfully a suburban history lesson on transit, along with bringing an old trolley to the Wellston Station is not the answer. A trolley is unlikely to attract new visitors with the real thing a couple of miles down the road. It is the absolute last thing this neighborhood needs at this time
    An effort to bring public space and its flexibility, to consider transit routes and their economic and social impact is more along the lines of efforts that will contribute to success.
    The discussion of public space has to include discussions of density. The Commons in Grand Center is a public space for events only. There is not a natural flow of people feeding the Commons because of a massive parking garage across the street. The Commons seldom has people in it without an event.
    The key to development of public space is to populate a space at all times. Thus transit collection points become important. This is along with people who create density through apartments, shops or other uses, they represent the base users of the space.
    The failure of St. Louis in my mind and MLK in particular is the failure to complete these understandings in order to build better human environments.
    And I totally disagree with the idea of a trolley history memorial. A living public space would be far better, even the statue of MLK in the middle of the road would have more lasting and significant impact on the neighborhood. (How many roads go around a statue in St. Lous)
    One final note on the rehab of Wellston Station, Union West had some donors of which one may still be interested in helping, if you are thinking about forming a nonprofit, approach Beyond Housing first. They also have control of the building next to the MLK/Rock Road Rail Station in Pagedale, so they have direct relevance, at least from a transit point of view, to any activities at Wellston Station and beyond. They are also working intensively in Normandy School District,with their 24/1 imitative. Wellston Station is part of this area although not in the Normandy School District.
    I better stop before I get banned for talking too much.

  • Nick

    I wonder what the implications are for the Great Streets Initiative with that part of MLK being HWY-180. I would think any street (ahem, highway) changes would have to involve Modot who has not shown themselves to be very progressive when it comes making streets more vibrant. I’m thinking of Modot’s Gravois “improvements” that are currently underway.

  • marca stewart

    Welcome to UTOPIA!

    • Adam

      That’s marca! (Imagine saying it like “That’s Quaqmire!” on Family Guy.)

      • marca stewart

        As I told you before Sir: You are and IDIOT! Go back in the corner now and sit quiet.

        • Adam

          I will if you will.

  • Guest

    Certainly want the very best for Wellston community. Hope that the new development materializes and that it serves the community well.

    • Riggle

      Except its not in wellston. Its in st louis. Kinda like the “ucity” trolley. Which is also mostly in St Louis…

  • Wabash

    While PCC cars would be nice, there are two beautiful Peter Witt streetcars – one sitting in the Loop, the other at the History Museum – which may need a new home (or at least could serve a better purpose) after the Loop/History Museum have their actual trolley running.

    Wellston would be a great home for those two, and if a PCC becomes available all the better.

  • tbatts666

    My biggest question is what are the barriers to incremental investment in the area?

    Really interesting critique. When I bike down this section of Martin Luther King I’m always amazed at how good these buildings are, if somewhat run down.

    • Imran

      As someone who is about to start a rehab on a historic building near here, I can tell you there are many barriers. For eg. I have great credit and I had to look forever for a bank that was willing to risk giving me a loan to invest in this area (did finally find one). I cant imagine how someone with more modest means would ever get the funds to fix up their house or building. There is a system-wide bias against certain zip codes (modern day red-lining if you will) .

  • rgbose

    A segment from World Wide Magazine contains some shots of the Wellston station.
    https://youtu.be/zFnuoChKYf8?t=2m40s

    • I love the old Bi-State logo and green and white color scheme. MetroLink trains would look so sharp in those colors!